A weathered wooden yoke on a rough table in warm dawn light

Devotional commentary · October 29

Substitution

He made the one who did not know sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

2 Corinthians 5:21 CSB
8 points · about 5 min
Read original ↗ (utmost.org, opens in a new tab)

Start hereThe Big Idea

Chambers says Jesus did not die merely out of sympathy for us but in obedience to the Father, identifying Himself with our sin. The substitution the New Testament teaches is twofold: He was made sin for us so that we might become His righteousness, which means Christ being formed in us.

Follow the readingEight Points

Tap a point to open it. Quotes are Chambers’ own words; ¶ marks his paragraph.

  • “He took our sin on Himself not because of sympathy, but because of His identification with us”

    — Oswald Chambers

    Chambers contrasts what he calls the modern view, that Jesus died out of sympathy for us, with the New Testament view. Sympathy stands alongside someone in their trouble. Identification goes further: Jesus took our place and was “made… to be sin.” The Cross is not just compassion; it is Christ entering fully into our condition.

  • “the only explanation for His death is His obedience to His Father, not His sympathy for us”

    — Oswald Chambers

    We might expect Chambers to locate the Cross mainly in Jesus’ feelings toward us. Instead he points to the Son’s obedience to the Father. This roots our salvation in God’s purpose, not in human emotion. The love of God is real, but it is expressed through a Son who did His Father’s will to the end.

  • Chambers says we are acceptable to God not because we have obeyed or promised to give things up, but because of the death of Christ and for no other reason.

    This sentence leaves no room for mixed foundations. Our promises, sacrifices, and good intentions cannot be the ground of our acceptance. Only the death of Christ is.

  • Chambers says that while people say Jesus came to reveal God’s fatherhood and kindness, the New Testament says He came to take “away the sin of the world!” (John 1:29). The Father is revealed to those who know Jesus as Savior; to the world Jesus spoke of being a stumbling block (John 15:22-24), and John 14:9 was spoken to His disciples.

    Chambers does not deny that Jesus reveals the Father. He insists on the order. We come to know God as Father by first meeting Jesus as the One who takes away sin. Skipping the Cross to admire Jesus as a teacher of God’s kindness misses the reason He came.

  • “That Christ died for me, and therefore I am completely free from penalty, is never taught in the New Testament.”

    — Oswald Chambers

    This is a bold statement, and Chambers means it to unsettle a comfortable version of the gospel. He is not denying forgiveness. He is warning against a view that treats the Cross as a release from penalty with no change in us.

  • Chambers says the New Testament teaches that “He died for all” (2 Corinthians 5:15), not “He died my death,” and that through identification with His death we can be freed from sin and receive His righteousness as a gift.

    Our part is to be identified with Christ in His death. As we are joined to Him, sin loses its hold, and His righteousness is imparted to us as a gift. It is the life of Christ given to those who belong to Him.

  • “The substitution which is taught in the New Testament is twofold”

    — Oswald Chambers

    Chambers then quotes our key verse. Christ was made sin for us, and we become the righteousness of God in Him. Both halves matter. If we hold only the first, we have a pardon without a new life. The full exchange gives us both forgiveness and a transformed heart.

  • Chambers closes by saying the teaching is not “Christ for me” unless I am determined to have Christ formed in me (Galatians 4:19).

    Christ for us and Christ in us belong together. Chambers calls us to a settled determination to let Christ be formed in our character, choices, and habits. The Cross that saves us also shapes us, and we cooperate by yielding to that work day by day.

Two ways to live itThe Simple Takeaway

Picture two people who both believe Jesus died for them.

Person ATreats the Cross mainly as a release from penalty. They are grateful to be forgiven, but they see little need for change, and their faith stays in the background of an otherwise unchanged life.
Person BReceives forgiveness as the beginning of an exchange. They ask God to form Christ in them, so that His righteousness shows up in how they speak, work, forgive, and serve.

An everyday example: Picture a man who has long known he is forgiven but still holds a grudge against his brother. One morning he realizes that Christ for him also means Christ in him. He calls his brother, asks to meet for coffee, and begins the slow work of making peace.

ReflectOne Question to Sit With

Are you content with Christ for you, or are you determined to have Christ formed in you?

Excerpts from My Utmost for His Highest by Oswald Chambers, Updated Edition, © 1992 by Oswald Chambers Publications Association, Ltd., are quoted for commentary; read the full devotional at utmost.org. This is independent analysis and commentary, not affiliated with or endorsed by Our Daily Bread Ministries. Key verse: CSB.

Find a devotional

Search titles and commentary text. Results update as you type.